Is First or Second Harvest Matcha Better

Alright, let’s dig deeper into the world of matcha, the vibrant green tea that’s more than just a drink – it’s an experience. If you’ve ever sipped on this frothy goodness, you know it’s got a unique flavor that’s hard to beat.

But did you know there’s a big debate in the matcha community about whether the first or second harvest is better? Yeah, it’s a thing. So, is first or second harvest matcha better? Let’s break it down and find out!

What is Matcha?

So, what’s the deal with matcha anyway? Matcha is a type of powdered green tea that’s been a big deal in Japan for centuries, especially in traditional tea ceremonies. Unlike regular green tea where you steep the leaves, with matcha, you’re actually drinking the whole leaf, which is ground into a fine powder. This means you’re getting all the good stuff – the nutrients, the antioxidants, everything.

Now, making matcha is an art form. Here’s how it goes down:

  1. Shading the Plants: A few weeks before harvest, the tea plants are covered to block out direct sunlight. This boosts the chlorophyll levels, giving matcha its vibrant green color and rich flavor.
  2. Harvesting: When the time is right, the youngest, most tender leaves are handpicked.
  3. Steaming: The leaves are quickly steamed to stop fermentation and preserve that fresh green taste.
  4. Drying and Grinding: The leaves are then dried and slowly ground into a fine powder using stone mills. This process is super slow to avoid burning the leaves and losing flavor.

And voila! You have matcha, ready to be whisked into a frothy, delicious drink.

First Harvest Matcha (Ichibancha)

Let’s talk about first harvest matcha, or as the pros call it, Ichibancha.

  • Timing of the First Harvest: This happens in early spring, typically around May. The tea leaves are young and tender, picked at their absolute peak.
  • Quality and Characteristics: Ichibancha is the gold standard of matcha. These leaves are bursting with nutrients, giving you a super vibrant green powder that’s silky smooth. It’s packed with amino acids, especially L-theanine, which is what makes the flavor so rich and complex.
  • Flavor Profile and Taste Experience: First harvest matcha is all about that sweet, creamy flavor. It’s got a natural sweetness and a buttery texture that makes each sip feel like a little ceremony. There’s no bitterness here – just smooth, sweet umami goodness.
  • My 2cents: I’ll never forget my visit to a tea farm in Uji during the first harvest. The aroma of those freshly picked leaves was like nothing else. The tea master prepared a bowl of Ichibancha for me, and wow – the first sip was pure bliss. It was smooth, sweet, and almost had this creamy finish. It felt like I was drinking liquid springtime. Trust me, once you’ve had first harvest matcha, you’ll get why it’s considered the best. And, I guarantee that you’ll never think matcha tastes like grass. The second harvest matcha maybe, but never the first harvest.

Second Harvest Matcha (Nibancha)

Now, let’s get into second harvest matcha, known as Nibancha.

  • Timing of the Second Harvest: This one comes around in late June or July, after the first flush of leaves has been picked.
  • Quality and Characteristics: The leaves in the second harvest are a bit more mature and have been soaking up the summer sun. While still good, they don’t quite hit the high notes of the first harvest. The color isn’t as vibrant, and the powder might be a tad coarser.
  • Flavor Profile and Taste Experience: Second harvest matcha has a stronger, more robust flavor. It’s less sweet and more astringent, with a bit of that grassy, vegetal vibe. Think of it as matcha with a bit more attitude – it’s got that extra kick that some people really dig.
  • Personal Experience and Anecdote: I remember my trip to Shizuoka during the second harvest season. The tea farm had this earthy smell that was super inviting. When I tried the Nibancha, it was like a wake-up call for my taste buds – stronger, slightly bitter, but in a good way. It didn’t have the same smoothness as the first harvest, but it was perfect for a matcha latte. The robust flavor held its own against the milk and sweetener. If you like your matcha with a bit more punch, second harvest might be your new fave.

Nutritional Differences

Alright, let’s break down the nutritional side of things when it comes to first and second harvest matcha.

  • Comparison of Nutrients in First and Second Harvest Matcha: First harvest matcha, or Ichibancha, is like the overachiever in the class. It’s packed with more nutrients, thanks to those young, tender leaves. You get higher levels of amino acids, vitamins (especially A, C, and E), and antioxidants. The second harvest, Nibancha, still has good stuff but in slightly lower concentrations. It’s like comparing a fresh green salad to cooked greens – both healthy, but one’s got a bit more of the raw, powerful goodness.
  • Health Benefits Associated with Each:
    • First Harvest Matcha: This is your go-to for the ultimate health boost. The high levels of L-theanine help with relaxation and focus without the jitters you get from coffee. It’s also rich in catechins, particularly EGCG, which are powerful antioxidants. These help fight inflammation, support heart health, and even boost metabolism. Plus, those extra vitamins can give your immune system a nice little boost.
    • Second Harvest Matcha: Still awesome, just a bit less intense. You’ll get a good dose of antioxidants and vitamins, making it great for daily health maintenance. It’s also beneficial for metabolism and energy levels, just not as potent as the first harvest. If you’re drinking matcha regularly and want something a bit more budget-friendly but still nutritious, Nibancha is a solid choice.

In a nutshell, both types of matcha are great for you, but if you’re looking for the maximum health kick, first harvest is where it’s at.

Price Comparison

Let’s talk dollars and cents when it comes to matcha.

  • Cost of First Harvest Matcha: First harvest matcha, or Ichibancha, is the premium stuff. Because it’s packed with more nutrients and has that sweet, smooth flavor, it’s naturally going to cost more. Think of it like buying organic, grass-fed beef versus regular beef – you’re paying for quality. Expect to shell out a bit more for this top-tier matcha, but trust me, it’s worth every penny if you’re after the best taste and health benefits.
  • Cost of Second Harvest Matcha: Second harvest matcha, or Nibancha, is a bit more wallet-friendly. It’s still good quality but doesn’t quite reach the heights of the first harvest. This makes it a great everyday option if you’re on a budget but still want to enjoy the perks of matcha. You get the robust flavor and solid nutritional benefits without breaking the bank.

So, whether you’re splurging on first harvest for special occasions or stocking up on second harvest for daily sips, there’s a matcha to fit every budget.

When to Use Each Type

Alright, now let’s figure out when to whip out that first harvest matcha and when to go for the second harvest.

  • Ideal Uses for First Harvest Matcha: This is your go-to for those special moments. Think of it as the champagne of matcha. Use it when you want to truly savor the flavor. It’s perfect for traditional tea ceremonies, straight-up sipping as usucha (thin tea) or koicha (thick tea), and any time you want to impress with the best. Basically, anytime you want the full matcha experience in all its sweet, creamy glory, reach for the first harvest.
  • Ideal Uses for Second Harvest Matcha: Second harvest matcha is your everyday hero. It’s great for mixing into lattes, smoothies, or even baking. Its stronger, more robust flavor can hold its own against milk, sweeteners, and other ingredients. So, if you’re whipping up a matcha latte, making matcha-infused desserts, or just need a daily pick-me-up, second harvest is your matcha of choice. It’s versatile, budget-friendly, and still gives you that matcha goodness.

So, whether it’s a special occasion or just a regular Tuesday, there’s a matcha for that!


Alright, let’s wrap this up.

  • Recap of Key Points: We’ve dived deep into the world of matcha, breaking down the differences between first and second harvests. First harvest matcha (Ichibancha) is the premium, nutrient-packed, sweet, and creamy option, perfect for those special occasions and traditional tea ceremonies. Second harvest matcha (Nibancha) is your everyday go-to, with a robust flavor that’s great for lattes, smoothies, and baking, and it’s easier on the wallet.
  • Final Thoughts on Which is Better Depending on Preference and Use: So, which is better? It really boils down to what you’re looking for. If you want the highest quality, best flavor, and maximum health benefits, go for the first harvest matcha. It’s a bit pricier, but totally worth it for the ultimate matcha experience. On the other hand, if you’re looking for something more affordable that still packs a punch, second harvest matcha is a fantastic choice for your daily dose of green goodness.

Whether you’re treating yourself to the best or just need a solid everyday matcha, there’s no wrong choice here. Happy sipping!

Additional Tips

Alright, let’s make sure your matcha stays as fresh and tasty as the day you got it. Here are some pro tips for storing your matcha:

  • Keep it Cool: Matcha hates heat. Store it in a cool spot, like a pantry or cupboard, away from any heat sources like stoves or dishwashers.
  • Avoid Light: Light is matcha’s worst enemy. Use an opaque, airtight container to keep your matcha safe from light exposure. Those dark tins or ceramic jars work great.
  • Stay Dry: Humidity is a no-go. Make sure your matcha stays dry. Avoid the fridge, unless you live in a super hot and humid climate. If you do refrigerate, keep it in an airtight container and let it come to room temperature before opening to avoid condensation.
  • Portion Control: Only open what you need. If you’ve got a big bag of matcha, transfer some to a smaller container for daily use and keep the rest sealed tightly.
  • Use It Up: Matcha is best enjoyed fresh. Try to use it within a few weeks of opening. The longer it sits, the more it loses its vibrant flavor and nutrients.

For a detailed guide, click the following: How To Store Matcha.

With these tips, your matcha will stay fresh, flavorful, and ready to give you that perfect cup every time. Happy matcha-ing!

Written by

Read more

Leave a comment